Post by Derek GeePost by hislopLast night I took the bluray of Wings 4:3 silent movie, and tried to get
it to show properly on my tv which was set to 4:3. This involved setting
the bluray player to output at 480p/576p. I could not get it to look
right.
I think the best was when I used the zoom on the tv as well, which can't
be done with a CRT tv. I tried various settings on the bluray player, I
now understand the problem. bluray just isn't in 4:3.
DVDs will have 4:3 which is then stretched to 16:9 (anamorphic). I don't
believe anything of the kind happens with bluray.
Tell us more about your TV. An older CRT tv will not be able to display a
480p signal, only a 480i.
I thought of that afterwards, maybe makes no difference for this
experiment. I could set the bluray player output to 480i/576i. Any LCD
TV does some type of de-interlacing I think, like a computer does.
Not sure what you're player will do without
Post by Derek Geelooking at the manual. My Panasonic doesn't indicate it can display a 4:3
image at full 4:3 size on a CRT. I suspect it would windowbox the 4:3 image
within a letterboxed 16:9 image output to the CRT.
With 480p/576p the tv signal will be 4:3. I set the TV to 'normal' for
that, 'full' is the stretched 16:9 for anamorphic.
Then I set the DVD/bluray player accordingly. I set the bluray output
to 4:3. It was the top of the range Sony one from earlier this year.
With 'normal' on the TV, it is identical to any 4:3 TV but with added
pillarboxing. You can't get the 'normal' option with HD.
There are a few variations for the player. 'original' or 'fixed ratio'
for example. I've only been using a player with HDMI this year. I've
discovered the odd DVD that has been set wrong, so you can't get a
proper 4:3 picture with the upconverted 1080 setting (the look is
entirely determined by the DVD's own details). I've actually fixed them
by reburning and using Ifoedit for changing the settings. There was a
series of Chaplin DVDs that seem to be all set wrong.
But I can do nothing for bluray on 4:3 the same way. Bluray authoring
is too arcane for me if it is even possible which I doubt.
I saw a lot of variations on the picture for Wings, all in 4:3,
letterboxed or squished for example. But no proper 4:3 without cheating
with the TV's zoom.